Peel and Stick vs. Traditional Wallpaper: Which Should You Choose?

You've found the perfect wallpaper pattern. Now comes the question that stops many first-time buyers: should you get it in peel and stick or traditional format? Both have their place, and the right choice depends on your space, your lifestyle, and your long-term plans.

At Mayflower Wallpaper, we offer most of our patterns in both formats because we believe you should choose based on your situation, not our inventory. Here's how to make that choice.

Peel and Stick vs. Traditional: The Complete Comparison

What Is Peel and Stick Wallpaper?

Peel and stick wallpaper comes with a pressure-sensitive adhesive already applied to the backing. Installation is straightforward: peel off the protective liner and press the wallpaper onto the wall, repositioning as needed until you're satisfied.

Modern peel and stick is far from the vinyl contact paper of decades past. Today's options include woven fabric materials that feel substantial, textured finishes that mimic traditional wallpaper, and eco-friendly materials free of PVC and harmful chemicals.

Our peel and stick collection is what we call "like a long sticker"—easy to apply alone and always renter-friendly. Every pattern is PVC-free, VOC-free, and phthalate-free, printed with eco-friendly inks.

What Is Traditional Wallpaper?

Traditional wallpaper requires a separate adhesive. The three main types are unpasted (requires separately mixed paste), pre-pasted (adhesive activated with water), and non-woven (paste applied directly to the wall).

Traditional wallpaper has been the standard for centuries and remains the choice for professional installations and high-end applications. At Mayflower, our traditional patterns come as double rolls (20.5" x 11 yards), covering approximately 56 square feet with minimal seams.

Does Peel and Stick Wallpaper Damage Walls?

When properly applied and removed, quality peel and stick wallpaper does not damage walls. The adhesive releases cleanly without taking paint or drywall paper with it.

The key factors are surface preparation (walls must be clean, smooth, and fully cured if recently painted), quality materials (cheap options may use aggressive adhesives), and proper removal technique (slow, steady pulling at a 45-degree angle).

We stand behind our peel and stick—but always recommend testing in an inconspicuous area if you're concerned about your specific wall finish.

How Long Does Each Type Last?

Traditional wallpaper can last 15 years or more with proper installation and care. It's the durability champion.

Quality peel and stick typically lasts 5+ years, and some installations last even longer in ideal conditions (climate-controlled rooms, low humidity, smooth walls).

At Mayflower, our traditional Westerly Clouds (FJ30901) and Morrissey patterns are designed for permanent installations. Our peel and stick versions offer the same beautiful design with built-in flexibility.

Which Is Easier to Install?

Peel and stick wins for ease. No mixing paste, no water trays, no mess. You can reposition panels during installation. Most homeowners complete a single accent wall in 2-3 hours.

Traditional wallpaper requires more skill. Non-woven traditional (paste on the wall) has made DIY more accessible, but there's still a learning curve. Many people hire professionals for entire rooms or complex patterns.

What About Humid Rooms Like Bathrooms?

Humidity is where traditional wallpaper has a clear advantage. The adhesive bond is stronger and more moisture-resistant over time.

Peel and stick can work in bathrooms with good ventilation but may peel at edges in consistently humid environments. Our peel and stick is water-resistant vinyl that handles normal kitchen conditions well.

What Mayflower Offers in Each Format

Both formats are designed and printed in Rhode Island with eco-friendly inks. Both are PVC-free, VOC-free, and phthalate-free. The quality is consistent—only the installation method differs.

Making Your Decision

Choose peel and stick if: you're renting, want DIY installation, plan to update your design down the road, want to avoid paste, or are testing a bold pattern.

Choose traditional if: you own your home and want maximum durability, you're installing in humid environments, you want a 15+ year installation, or you're hiring professional installers anyway.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I put peel and stick wallpaper over existing wallpaper?

Not recommended. The adhesive needs direct wall contact for proper bonding. Remove existing wallpaper first.

Can I use peel and stick on textured walls?

Light texture is usually fine. Heavy texture (knockdown, popcorn) prevents proper adhesion and shows through. Skim coating creates a smooth surface for any wallpaper.

Do I need to prime walls before peel and stick?

Freshly painted walls should cure 30 days before application. Priming isn't required but can improve adhesion on porous surfaces.

What do customers say about Mayflower Wallpaper?

Customers appreciate that we offer the same patterns in both formats, letting them choose based on their situation. They also mention our print quality, responsive service, and helpful guidance on calculating quantities.

Which type is better for the environment?

Both our traditional and peel-and-stick wallpapers are printed with eco-friendly inks at American mills. American-made means shorter shipping distances and a smaller carbon footprint versus imported alternatives.

Ready to transform your space? Order samples for $5 with free shipping. Shop our Peel and Stick Collection for renter-friendly options, or browse Traditional Wallpaper for lasting durability.

Whether you choose peel and stick or traditional, the most important factor is finding a pattern you love from a manufacturer you trust. Both formats can transform your space beautifully. Consider your lifestyle, your timeline, and your walls—then make the choice that fits. And remember, samples are always worth ordering before you commit. Questions? We're happy to help with honest recommendations for your specific project.